Misinformation spread over India’s Citizenship Amendment discussed in Geneva « Khabarhub
Sunday, July 21st, 2024

Misinformation spread over India’s Citizenship Amendment discussed in Geneva


29 February 2020  

Time taken to read : 4 Minute


  • A
  • A
  • A

GENEVA: The Parliament of India passed the Citizenship Amendment Act (CAA) which amended the Citizenship Act of 1955 on 11 December 2019 to fight against illegal migration.

The CAA grants citizenship to the six religious communities including Hindu, Sikh, Buddhist, Jain, Parsi, and Christian of Afghanistan, Pakistan and Bangladesh that have faced religious persecution in these countries.

However, it was criticized for discriminating against people according to their religion by not including the Muslim community as one of the beneficiaries of the citizenship.

The new provisions brought by the CAA and the situation of Muslims were clarified by the Member of Parliament in Rajya Sabha, Mobasher Jawed Akbar, the Chief Imam of India Umer Ahmed Ilyasi, the Member of European Parliament Fulvio Martusciello, Journalist Atika Ahmed Farooqui and the Executive Director of South Asia Democratic Forum (SADF) Paulo Casaca.

The panel was moderated by Brian Toll who is the former Director of the European Commission and the South Asia Expert.

M.J. Akbar mentioned that the most important characteristic of India is its plurality and the Constitution gives equal rights to everyone irrespective of religion.

Moreover, India does accept any ‘-ism’ and the only -ism for them is democracy. He concluded his words quoting from Mahatma Gandhi, “Hindus and Muslims are one. God created them and no one can separate them”.

Fulvio Martusciello, insisting on the ever-present brotherhood and peace in the country, stated that the CAA will not affect the rights of minorities and it has no provisions that include Indian citizens.

With this act, several rights including electoral and educational rights will be given through Indian citizenship to the persons who have been faced with religious persecution in their country.

Ahmed Ilyasi drew the attention to the Muslim community in India stating that “India has the second-largest number of Muslims in the world…and it welcomes all diverse viewpoints”.

Providing equal citizenship for everyone, India is a secular democracy that does not allow any privilege based on religion. Moreover, he mentioned that unlike the Muslims in Europe, the Muslims in India were not radicalized and participated in Jihadist movements.

He concluded that if any Muslim wants, he or she can still apply for citizenship satisfying the provisions of the Citizenship Act of 1955.

Atika Farooqui started her speech that neither she nor the Indians do not see the cast, gender, religion, or race when looking at someone. The religion in India according to Farooqui is considered a culture that makes the country colorful with food habits, languages, and dances.

She concluded with: “We, Indians, are just curious and hardworking people with Muslim, Christian, Sikh and Hindu sounding names”.

Paulo Casaca focused on the role of Europe in this disinformation campaign stating that the EU institutions are feeding the hatred and chaos.

He warned the EU to change its attitude first towards the refugees at its borders before interfering in India. He added that the CAA provides a special fast track procedure to certain groups from certain neighboring countries.

Brian Toll concluded the session mentioning that all are equal, and religion is not the prime factor of the integration of people in the country.

Publish Date : 29 February 2020 16:18 PM

RSP warns against unfounded accusations toward Deputy Speaker

KATHMANDU: Rastriya Swatantra Party (RSP) has cautioned against leveling unfounded

Nepali Congress demands Deputy Speaker Rana’s resignation amid US visa allegations

KATHMANDU: The Nepali Congress (NC) has called for the resignation

IN PICS: Nepali students return home amid Bangladesh protests

KATHMANDU: Nepali students have begun returning home from Bangladesh amid

Ward Chairman’s roadside office protests KMC’s New Road footpath expansion (With photos)

KATHMANDU: Chairman Chinikaji Maharjan of Kathmandu Metropolitan City (KMC) Ward-22

RSP declines to support PM Oli’s trust motion, issues whip to vote against Oli

KATHMANDU: The Rastriya Swatantra Party (RSP) has decided not to